Defining Cat Game

MSU Toddler · Post by **MSU Toddler** » Thu Oct 26, 2006 12:33 pm

i was thinking about this the other day and wondering the question should wait - but was bored, so i'm going to ask it (at the risk of attracting the posts of those just on this board to be a jerk).

do you think the Cats have played a complete game this year that defines who they are (one you can point to and say "that's the 2006 Bobcats")?

or do you think that has yet to happen?

and why (for both cases)?

if you want to do the same for other teams - take it to another part of the board (it is a good question for remaining foes).

thoughts?

ChiOCat · Post by **ChiOCat** » Thu Oct 26, 2006 1:01 pm

I didn't listen to the Colorado game, so it's out.

To me, NAU is the only game where we were in control of the game. The other ones I just felt lucky that time ran out while we were still ahead

I assume Colorado was similar to NAU, so let's bring that team back for the last 3 games!

Post by **rtb** » Thu Oct 26, 2006 1:09 pm

I think the Idaho State game is truly who this team is. We played great on offense and defense with a few mental mistakes that kept them in it. Our special teams is a question mark every game and will be that way for a while, but I think that is the 2006 Bobcat team.

crazycat · Post by **crazycat** » Thu Oct 26, 2006 1:22 pm

It definitely has yet to happen.

I don't think the defining game can be defined at this point. For instance, saying the NAU game is the defining game would be way off base if we lose on Saturday or Nov. 14 or Nov. 18. It may turn out that the defining game was the Chadron game. This would be a great conversation once we've played our last game.

STREETCAT · Post by **STREETCAT** » Thu Oct 26, 2006 1:25 pm

crazycat wrote:It definitely has yet to happen.

I don't think the defining game can be defined at this point. For instance, saying the NAU game is the defining game would be way off base if we lose on Saturday or Nov. 14 or Nov. 18. It may turn out that the defining game was the Chadron game. This would be a great conversation once we've played our last game.

I think that the PSU game was our most complete game. The D played Flawless and though our O didnt play its best game, we didnt make stupid turnover mistakes

nevadacat · Post by **nevadacat** » Thu Oct 26, 2006 1:42 pm

ChiOCat wrote:I didn't listen to the Colorado game, so it's out.

To me, NAU is the only game where we were in control of the game. The other ones I just felt lucky that time ran out while we were still ahead

I can't agree, defensively. The defense had a let down halfway through the 3rd quarter, then recovered late in the 4th quarter.

Between TV, radio, and the one live game I've seen, I can't say there's been one complete game overall, but PSU is as close as it's come. Or, split between the squads, PSU on defense, NAU on offense, Colorado on special teams.

94VegasCat · Post by **94VegasCat** » Thu Oct 26, 2006 3:06 pm

this thread is along the lines of what I was thinking when I started the thread about ALL THREE PHASES of the game. I am not so sure that we have played a complete game yet. If this team puts one together though.........WHOOOOOAAAAA NELLY!!!

El_Gato · Post by **El_Gato** » Thu Oct 26, 2006 3:11 pm

IMO, we have yet to play anything CLOSE to a complete game.

If we had, there'd be a 31-0 or 45-14 win on the schedule somewhere.

Methinks we're saving it for November 18th...

MSU Toddler · Post by **MSU Toddler** » Thu Oct 26, 2006 4:22 pm

i to find it difficult to think that the Cats have played the one game that really shows what they are capable on all facets of the game. i hope that it comes together - especially if it is for all the marbles on nov. 18th. the Cats are certainly trending in the right direction!

i would also agree that there have been games (i.e. D vs. psu, O vs. nau, isu) where each side of the ball has shined.

if i was forced to pick one game - i would go with isu though i think the final score was not indicative of the strength of the D.

orsalak · Post by **orsalak** » Thu Oct 26, 2006 8:41 pm

MSU Toddler wrote:i was thinking about this the other day and wondering the question should wait - but was bored, so i'm going to ask it (at the risk of attracting the posts of those just on this board to be a jerk).

do you think the Cats have played a complete game this year that defines who they are (one you can point to and say "that's the 2006 Bobcats")?

or do you think that has yet to happen?

and why (for both cases)?

if you want to do the same for other teams - take it to another part of the board (it is a good question for remaining foes).

PSU was close to being a full game. D showed its grit. O did what it needed to do.

083190 · Post by **083190** » Thu Oct 26, 2006 9:28 pm

Is the question whether there has been a complete game, or if there has been a defining game? Complete game-no. Defining game-ISU. Good at times, even spectacular. But then, brain cramps and few what the hell was thats? Followed by the was neat-good win.

Bcat · Post by **Bcat** » Fri Oct 27, 2006 1:02 am

One game does not define a team. I am looking for a serious of wins. A season defines a team, but more so the coaching staff. You can have all the talent you want on your side, put it together and all is good.

I will wait to declare a defining game until we have a defining season! Yes, we have a defining game, if we have a defining season. I'm glad we are on track, but, until we go into the playoff rounds, no use flappin our gumbs. I for one am going to hold my breath and not jinx this team. I'm tired of calling beating the Griz a winning season when I eat turkey and watch other teams play. If we are in it after Thanksgiving, I will post a defining game, I think there clearly is one recently played.

Please don't give me the, "where is the CAT attitude and loayality speach", I am loayal, that is why I am demanding a winning season, not merely a good game. Sorry, been here too many times to get over confident. Going into the playoffs is my demand for this program, anything less is giving an upper hand to the enemy, and is less than loyal! We deserve better, and better expect better. This program must go to the next level, and build year by year. We demand that of our players, we must demand that of this program. Let it fly, I expect greatness of MSU, and will defend that expectation until achieved.

Hell's Bells · Post by **Hell's Bells** » Fri Oct 27, 2006 8:03 am

chadron state or u.c.davis

**ducks**

94VegasCat · Post by **94VegasCat** » Fri Oct 27, 2006 8:44 am

Bcat wrote:One game does not define a team. I am looking for a serious of wins. A season defines a team, but more so the coaching staff. You can have all the talent you want on your side, put it together and all is good.

I will wait to declare a defining game until we have a defining season! Yes, we have a defining game, if we have a defining season. I'm glad we are on track, but, until we go into the playoff rounds, no use flappin our gumbs. I for one am going to hold my breath and not jinx this team. I'm tired of calling beating the Griz a winning season when I eat turkey and watch other teams play. If we are in it after Thanksgiving, I will post a defining game, I think there clearly is one recently played.

Please don't give me the, "where is the CAT attitude and loayality speach", I am loayal, that is why I am demanding a winning season, not merely a good game. Sorry, been here too many times to get over confident. Going into the playoffs is my demand for this program, anything less is giving an upper hand to the enemy, and is less than loyal! We deserve better, and better expect better. This program must go to the next level, and build year by year. We demand that of our players, we must demand that of this program. Let it fly, I expect greatness of MSU, and will defend that expectation until achieved.

Well put! I have been keeping quiet too. There are so many naysayers outside of Bozeman and I think that that is GREAT. We will be there when it is time to explode onto the scene IMHO.

94VegasCat · Post by **94VegasCat** » Fri Oct 27, 2006 8:44 am

ooops

MSU Toddler · Post by **MSU Toddler** » Fri Oct 27, 2006 9:07 am

excellent post Bcat!

Post by **kmax** » Fri Oct 27, 2006 9:50 am

Hell's Bells wrote:chadron state or u.c.davis

**ducks**

Alright, how did G.W. get access to Hell's account?

GOKATS · Post by **GOKATS** » Fri Oct 27, 2006 10:25 am

kmax wrote:
Hell's Bells wrote:chadron state or u.c.davis

**ducks**
Alright, how did G.W. get access to Hell's account?

Defining Cat Game

Defining Cat Game

Re: Defining Cat Game