Moderators unfair?
Moderators: rtb, kmax, SonomaCat
-
- BobcatNation Redshirt
- Posts: 16
- Joined: Sun Dec 04, 2005 11:59 am
Moderators unfair?
So im starting to get a little pissed off, the moderaters have taken two of my previous posts down, granted the first one was a little over the edged, but who knows maybe he did go into porn, nobody else was posting, so i had to do something, then i decided to make it a little better by apologizing, then longhorn started verbally harrassing me, this did not bother me too much, i try not to take things i read on the internet too personally because most of the stuff out there is fake anyhow. Which is another reason my first post should have been left, the only reason i did it was because it would get people talking, "NO HE ISNT GAY HE ACTUALLY DID THIS..." i was only trying to help longhorn out. Then he decides to take matters into his own hands and requests that i be banned, i would like to add that i also recieved a PM from him saying that i was gay and recieve...use your imagination...anyway, i did not appreciate that. As for the 'posting war' that occured, it was only in an effort to get the thread going, i have seen much worse posts than what longhorn and i where posting. I am highly dissappointed in the way the moderators handled the situation, i expect they will ban me because they are all a bunch of wankers who are too afraid to confront the parties involved, privately and ask nicely to remove the posts. Had they asked me to remove my post i would have gladly removed or edited my post. Also i think it was dumb that longhorn did not get his thread removed, he was equally responsible for what happened, he could have PMed the moderators instead of harrasing me and making personal shots at me. I did apologize though, so i leave it up to you....the readers, to decide what should be done...moderators, leave it to us to figure this one out. Dont get involved, i have not done anything wrong unless expressing my freedom of speech is wrong, or unless expressing my opinion on a FORUM is wrong, either way, i think this could have been handled a little differently.
Well what do you all think...
Well what do you all think...
- longhorn_22
- Golden Bobcat
- Posts: 7592
- Joined: Thu Feb 24, 2005 11:43 pm
- Location: Billings/Bozeman
Re: Moderators unfair?
No one cares what you have to say. You have useless posts here and no one wants to read them and waste their time. If everyone saw the posts you posted, they would all agree.user101 wrote:So im starting to get a little pissed off, the moderaters have taken two of my previous posts down, granted the first one was a little over the edged, but who knows maybe he did go into porn, nobody else was posting, so i had to do something, then i decided to make it a little better by apologizing, then longhorn started verbally harrassing me, this did not bother me too much, i try not to take things i read on the internet too personally because most of the stuff out there is fake anyhow. Which is another reason my first post should have been left, the only reason i did it was because it would get people talking, "NO HE ISNT GAY HE ACTUALLY DID THIS..." i was only trying to help longhorn out. Then he decides to take matters into his own hands and requests that i be banned, i would like to add that i also recieved a PM from him saying that i was gay and recieve...use your imagination...anyway, i did not appreciate that. As for the 'posting war' that occured, it was only in an effort to get the thread going, i have seen much worse posts than what longhorn and i where posting. I am highly dissappointed in the way the moderators handled the situation, i expect they will ban me because they are all a bunch of wankers who are too afraid to confront the parties involved, privately and ask nicely to remove the posts. Had they asked me to remove my post i would have gladly removed or edited my post. Also i think it was dumb that longhorn did not get his thread removed, he was equally responsible for what happened, he could have PMed the moderators instead of harrasing me and making personal shots at me. I did apologize though, so i leave it up to you....the readers, to decide what should be done...moderators, leave it to us to figure this one out. Dont get involved, i have not done anything wrong unless expressing my freedom of speech is wrong, or unless expressing my opinion on a FORUM is wrong, either way, i think this could have been handled a little differently.
Well what do you all think...
- wbtfg
- Golden Bobcat
- Posts: 14291
- Joined: Sat Apr 03, 2004 12:52 pm
Re: Moderators unfair?
Go Awayuser101 wrote:So im starting to get a little pissed off, the moderaters have taken two of my previous posts down, granted the first one was a little over the edged, but who knows maybe he did go into porn, nobody else was posting, so i had to do something, then i decided to make it a little better by apologizing, then longhorn started verbally harrassing me, this did not bother me too much, i try not to take things i read on the internet too personally because most of the stuff out there is fake anyhow. Which is another reason my first post should have been left, the only reason i did it was because it would get people talking, "NO HE ISNT GAY HE ACTUALLY DID THIS..." i was only trying to help longhorn out. Then he decides to take matters into his own hands and requests that i be banned, i would like to add that i also recieved a PM from him saying that i was gay and recieve...use your imagination...anyway, i did not appreciate that. As for the 'posting war' that occured, it was only in an effort to get the thread going, i have seen much worse posts than what longhorn and i where posting. I am highly dissappointed in the way the moderators handled the situation, i expect they will ban me because they are all a bunch of wankers who are too afraid to confront the parties involved, privately and ask nicely to remove the posts. Had they asked me to remove my post i would have gladly removed or edited my post. Also i think it was dumb that longhorn did not get his thread removed, he was equally responsible for what happened, he could have PMed the moderators instead of harrasing me and making personal shots at me. I did apologize though, so i leave it up to you....the readers, to decide what should be done...moderators, leave it to us to figure this one out. Dont get involved, i have not done anything wrong unless expressing my freedom of speech is wrong, or unless expressing my opinion on a FORUM is wrong, either way, i think this could have been handled a little differently.
Well what do you all think...
Monte eats corn the long way.
- rtb
- Moderator
- Posts: 8027
- Joined: Tue Mar 09, 2004 12:15 pm
- Location: Bend, OR
- Contact:
WOW!! First off posting that someone was gay based on no fact is a vaild reason for deleting a post. Second, did you let any moderator know that you were being harassed via private messages? I know I never received anything.
And calling us a bunch of wankers? How old are you? I am gladly going to leave this up to let the others on this board vote and let us moderators know how they feel.
I will say this...it is our board and we make the rules take it or leave it. If you want to spend a good portion of your free time creating a board for others get to it, otherwise don't come here and ruin what we have spent countless hours on.
And calling us a bunch of wankers? How old are you? I am gladly going to leave this up to let the others on this board vote and let us moderators know how they feel.
I will say this...it is our board and we make the rules take it or leave it. If you want to spend a good portion of your free time creating a board for others get to it, otherwise don't come here and ruin what we have spent countless hours on.
- longhorn_22
- Golden Bobcat
- Posts: 7592
- Joined: Thu Feb 24, 2005 11:43 pm
- Location: Billings/Bozeman
- rtb
- Moderator
- Posts: 8027
- Joined: Tue Mar 09, 2004 12:15 pm
- Location: Bend, OR
- Contact:
- longhorn_22
- Golden Bobcat
- Posts: 7592
- Joined: Thu Feb 24, 2005 11:43 pm
- Location: Billings/Bozeman
-
- BobcatNation Redshirt
- Posts: 16
- Joined: Sun Dec 04, 2005 11:59 am
Dear moderator,
i apologize for calling you a bunch of wankers. And as i explained in the thread, i understand why my first post was taken off, it was uncalled for, however, like i said, nobody else was posting anything, i just wanted to throw an outrageous comment out there to get things started. I now know that you know that longhorn was quite hurtful in his PM, i expect a punishment is in line, perhaps the one he set forth for me...BANISHMENT! I dont think you should go that extreme, but i do think you should rethink what you are doing, i am simply posting on a forum-a group discussion in which opinions are shared and discussed. Might i point out the word opinion, if i want to express my opinion on a website designed for this purpose, i will. i do believe that covers pretty much everything, so i think all that is left is to discuss what longhorn has coming to him. i have been punished and confronted, now i think he needs to be confronted, what better place then here, especially since my posts were deleted the second time for simply apologizing and then defending my self. It was rediculuos the way longhorn reacted to my apology.
Sincerely yours,
ME
i apologize for calling you a bunch of wankers. And as i explained in the thread, i understand why my first post was taken off, it was uncalled for, however, like i said, nobody else was posting anything, i just wanted to throw an outrageous comment out there to get things started. I now know that you know that longhorn was quite hurtful in his PM, i expect a punishment is in line, perhaps the one he set forth for me...BANISHMENT! I dont think you should go that extreme, but i do think you should rethink what you are doing, i am simply posting on a forum-a group discussion in which opinions are shared and discussed. Might i point out the word opinion, if i want to express my opinion on a website designed for this purpose, i will. i do believe that covers pretty much everything, so i think all that is left is to discuss what longhorn has coming to him. i have been punished and confronted, now i think he needs to be confronted, what better place then here, especially since my posts were deleted the second time for simply apologizing and then defending my self. It was rediculuos the way longhorn reacted to my apology.
Sincerely yours,
ME
- BozoneCat
- BobcatNation Hall of Famer
- Posts: 3227
- Joined: Mon Mar 29, 2004 7:15 pm
- Location: Boise, ID
Re: Moderators unfair?
I think you need to get lost.user101 wrote:So im starting to get a little pissed off, the moderaters have taken two of my previous posts down, granted the first one was a little over the edged, but who knows maybe he did go into porn, nobody else was posting, so i had to do something, then i decided to make it a little better by apologizing, then longhorn started verbally harrassing me, this did not bother me too much, i try not to take things i read on the internet too personally because most of the stuff out there is fake anyhow. Which is another reason my first post should have been left, the only reason i did it was because it would get people talking, "NO HE ISNT GAY HE ACTUALLY DID THIS..." i was only trying to help longhorn out. Then he decides to take matters into his own hands and requests that i be banned, i would like to add that i also recieved a PM from him saying that i was gay and recieve...use your imagination...anyway, i did not appreciate that. As for the 'posting war' that occured, it was only in an effort to get the thread going, i have seen much worse posts than what longhorn and i where posting. I am highly dissappointed in the way the moderators handled the situation, i expect they will ban me because they are all a bunch of wankers who are too afraid to confront the parties involved, privately and ask nicely to remove the posts. Had they asked me to remove my post i would have gladly removed or edited my post. Also i think it was dumb that longhorn did not get his thread removed, he was equally responsible for what happened, he could have PMed the moderators instead of harrasing me and making personal shots at me. I did apologize though, so i leave it up to you....the readers, to decide what should be done...moderators, leave it to us to figure this one out. Dont get involved, i have not done anything wrong unless expressing my freedom of speech is wrong, or unless expressing my opinion on a FORUM is wrong, either way, i think this could have been handled a little differently.
Well what do you all think...
- rtb
- Moderator
- Posts: 8027
- Joined: Tue Mar 09, 2004 12:15 pm
- Location: Bend, OR
- Contact:
Ok, AGAIN....DID YOU LET ANY OF THE MODERATORS KNOW ABOUT THE PMs? NO. I CAN'T DO MUCH ABOUT IT IF YOU DON'T LET US KNOW ABOUT IT PRIVATELY.
Second...you are fine to post your opinion....saying someone is gay based on no facts isn't an opinion...that is a LIE. If you want to get a thread moving simply type BUMP.
I told Longhorn to back off and he agreed. Now you have an option....Deal with the fact that this board is controlled by the moderators and our word is final...if you don't like it don't post here!!
Second...you are fine to post your opinion....saying someone is gay based on no facts isn't an opinion...that is a LIE. If you want to get a thread moving simply type BUMP.
I told Longhorn to back off and he agreed. Now you have an option....Deal with the fact that this board is controlled by the moderators and our word is final...if you don't like it don't post here!!
-
- BobcatNation Redshirt
- Posts: 16
- Joined: Sun Dec 04, 2005 11:59 am
I dont think people should keep telling me to "go away" and "get Lost" it is not right, i apologized for my acionts, and i am only requesting that longhorn recieve consequences for his actions. after he recieves his punishment i will be pleased. Until then i am simply discussing the incident, in a professional manner, i think you all should do the same.
- CelticCat
- Golden Bobcat
- Posts: 12292
- Joined: Thu Apr 01, 2004 12:55 pm
- Location: Upper Northwest WA
- Contact:
I have no idea what happened so I won't comment until I get the story.
I do believe some regular posters on this site get away with some out of line comments, but they make so many rational, well thought out posts that they have earned the right to step out of line once in a while. They have earned respect and the right to make some brash statements.
You, on the other hand, are new, and first impressions are the most important. If you got on the mods or any other posters bad side within your first day or two of joining the site, you deserve to take some flak.
That is the way message boards work. You have to earn respect and credibility. Why? Because we are a community. Online chums. Insult one of us, and you are insulting a lot of us.
Show respect and you'll receive it.
If you want to become a thoughtful, insightful poster on this site, I suggest everyone make up and you should explain your intentions to do so. If you are here just to stir things up, as you said, then you aren't going to last long.
I do believe some regular posters on this site get away with some out of line comments, but they make so many rational, well thought out posts that they have earned the right to step out of line once in a while. They have earned respect and the right to make some brash statements.
You, on the other hand, are new, and first impressions are the most important. If you got on the mods or any other posters bad side within your first day or two of joining the site, you deserve to take some flak.
That is the way message boards work. You have to earn respect and credibility. Why? Because we are a community. Online chums. Insult one of us, and you are insulting a lot of us.
Show respect and you'll receive it.
If you want to become a thoughtful, insightful poster on this site, I suggest everyone make up and you should explain your intentions to do so. If you are here just to stir things up, as you said, then you aren't going to last long.
R&R Cat Cast - the #1 Bobcat fan podcast - https://www.rrcatcast.com
Twitter - https://twitter.com/rrcatcast
Twitter - https://twitter.com/rrcatcast
- longhorn_22
- Golden Bobcat
- Posts: 7592
- Joined: Thu Feb 24, 2005 11:43 pm
- Location: Billings/Bozeman
- rtb
- Moderator
- Posts: 8027
- Joined: Tue Mar 09, 2004 12:15 pm
- Location: Bend, OR
- Contact:
Seriously....if you can't handle people telling you to go away, this isn't the place for you. You know you stirred the pot and people will be upset and on your case. Longhorn received a warning just like everyone else who has made personal comments. If they continue to happen we will take further action.user101 wrote:I dont think people should keep telling me to "go away" and "get Lost" it is not right, i apologized for my acionts, and i am only requesting that longhorn recieve consequences for his actions. after he recieves his punishment i will be pleased. Until then i am simply discussing the incident, in a professional manner, i think you all should do the same.
-
- Member # Retired
- Posts: 2081
- Joined: Mon Oct 10, 2005 4:11 pm
- Location: Bozeman, Montana
- Contact:
When I finally decided to start posting on BobcatNation, I told myself that I would only post if it would bring thoughtful insight to the world of Bobcat Athletics. It's also permissible to have a little bit of fun and most certainly possible to make a quip or a joke here and there. But name calling is just flat out not called for unless it's in the smack talk section, and there again in good fun. BobcatNation is too good of a place to screw it up by petty name calling. The moderators do a good job with keeping things in line here.
So come on people, let's keep BobcatNation as the place to discuss Bobcat Athletics intelligently, not just a place where people argue just to insult each other.

GO CATS!
It's always a good day to be a Bobcat fan!

My name is Steve, if you'd like to know.
It's always a good day to be a Bobcat fan!



My name is Steve, if you'd like to know.
-
- BobcatNation Redshirt
- Posts: 16
- Joined: Sun Dec 04, 2005 11:59 am
OKAY THATS IT....HERES MY OPINION, YOU ARE ALL ****** DUMB ******, I HAVE BEEN TRYING TO EXPLAIN MY POSITIONING IN A TIMELY MANNER. I AM GIVING YOU ALL ONE LAST SHOT TO APOLOGIZE TO ME, BEFORE I REALLY LET LOOSE, MODERATOR, I AM NEW AT THIS WHOLE FORUM THING, AND ALL THIS HAPPENED SO FAST THAT I DIDNT KNOW I WAS SUPPOSED TO PM THE MODERATOR, I FIGURED PEOPLE DID THAT STUFF ALL OF THE TIME. ALSO, YOU DELETED THE POST...YOU SAW THE SHOTS LONGHORN WAS TAKING AT ME, WHY DIDNT YOU DO SOMETHING THEN, YOU COULD HAVE PM BOTH OF US AND TOLD US TO QUIT. BUT IM NOT HOLDING A GRUDGE ABOUT THAT, ALL THIS STARTED BECAUSE JAY HACKETT IS GAY, IN MY OPINION, OKAY THERE I SAID IT, I THINK JAY HACKETT IS GAY, A GOOD PLAYER, BUT GAY, THERES JUST SOMETHING IN HIS EYES THAT MAKES ME THINK SO, THERES YOUR SO CALLED 'PROOF' SO THERES MY OPINION, DROP THAT POINT.
NEXT
YOU NEED TO TREAT PEOPLE EQUALLY, LONGHORN IS AN EXPERIENCED POSTER, HE SHOULD HAVE CONTACTED YOU TO BEGIN WITH WHEN I POSTED THE JAY HACKETT COMMENT, AND YOU SHOULD HAVE TAKEN ACTION WHEN YOU DELETED MY POSTS.
NEXT
I AM NEW TO THIS, I DONT WANT TO POST ANYWHERE ELSE BECAUSE I LIKE THIS FORUM, I HAVE BEEN READING IT FOR A WHILE AND DECIDED TO JOIN, DONT GET MAD AT ME FOR NOT KNOWING ALL OF THE RULES.
SUMMARY.
THIS IS ALL JUST A STUPID CONTROVERSY BETWEEN A COUPLE OF MEMBERS, SOME PEOPLE DIDNT DO THEIR JOBS RIGHT AND SOME PEOPLE OUTLASHED TOWARDS OTHERS INAPPROPRIATELY, SO LETS JUST ALL ASSUME RESPONSIBILITY.
I HAVE A FEELING THAT THIS IS ALL OVERWITH AS OF NOW, AND IF ITS NOT ALL HELL IS GONNA BREAK LOOSE.
NEXT
YOU NEED TO TREAT PEOPLE EQUALLY, LONGHORN IS AN EXPERIENCED POSTER, HE SHOULD HAVE CONTACTED YOU TO BEGIN WITH WHEN I POSTED THE JAY HACKETT COMMENT, AND YOU SHOULD HAVE TAKEN ACTION WHEN YOU DELETED MY POSTS.
NEXT
I AM NEW TO THIS, I DONT WANT TO POST ANYWHERE ELSE BECAUSE I LIKE THIS FORUM, I HAVE BEEN READING IT FOR A WHILE AND DECIDED TO JOIN, DONT GET MAD AT ME FOR NOT KNOWING ALL OF THE RULES.
SUMMARY.
THIS IS ALL JUST A STUPID CONTROVERSY BETWEEN A COUPLE OF MEMBERS, SOME PEOPLE DIDNT DO THEIR JOBS RIGHT AND SOME PEOPLE OUTLASHED TOWARDS OTHERS INAPPROPRIATELY, SO LETS JUST ALL ASSUME RESPONSIBILITY.
I HAVE A FEELING THAT THIS IS ALL OVERWITH AS OF NOW, AND IF ITS NOT ALL HELL IS GONNA BREAK LOOSE.
-
- Golden Bobcat
- Posts: 4954
- Joined: Mon Jul 19, 2004 2:09 pm
- Location: Minneapolis, MN
I honestly think the moderators do an EXCELLENT job. You really have to FU - UP to get kicked off and then you usually get fair warning. They remove posts or move them as they see fit. This is a thankless tough job and they are doing it as well as could be expected. You have to let a lot of stuff go or the site would get stale but you have to preserve some small amount of fairness and integrity. They got after me once and I deserved it. Plus they were very fair and professional in how they did it. If you are not happy don't blame the Moderators!
Gary Tapp
Graduated MSU 1981
Hamilton High School
Minneapolis, MN
Graduated MSU 1981
Hamilton High School
Minneapolis, MN
- longhorn_22
- Golden Bobcat
- Posts: 7592
- Joined: Thu Feb 24, 2005 11:43 pm
- Location: Billings/Bozeman
I have contacted the moderators. Ive PMed them two or three times actually.user101 wrote:OKAY THATS IT....HERES MY OPINION, YOU ARE ALL ****** DUMB ******, I HAVE BEEN TRYING TO EXPLAIN MY POSITIONING IN A TIMELY MANNER. I AM GIVING YOU ALL ONE LAST SHOT TO APOLOGIZE TO ME, BEFORE I REALLY LET LOOSE, MODERATOR, I AM NEW AT THIS WHOLE FORUM THING, AND ALL THIS HAPPENED SO FAST THAT I DIDNT KNOW I WAS SUPPOSED TO PM THE MODERATOR, I FIGURED PEOPLE DID THAT STUFF ALL OF THE TIME. ALSO, YOU DELETED THE POST...YOU SAW THE SHOTS LONGHORN WAS TAKING AT ME, WHY DIDNT YOU DO SOMETHING THEN, YOU COULD HAVE PM BOTH OF US AND TOLD US TO QUIT. BUT IM NOT HOLDING A GRUDGE ABOUT THAT, ALL THIS STARTED BECAUSE JAY HACKETT IS GAY, IN MY OPINION, OKAY THERE I SAID IT, I THINK JAY HACKETT IS GAY, A GOOD PLAYER, BUT GAY, THERES JUST SOMETHING IN HIS EYES THAT MAKES ME THINK SO, THERES YOUR SO CALLED 'PROOF' SO THERES MY OPINION, DROP THAT POINT.
NEXT
YOU NEED TO TREAT PEOPLE EQUALLY, LONGHORN IS AN EXPERIENCED POSTER, HE SHOULD HAVE CONTACTED YOU TO BEGIN WITH WHEN I POSTED THE JAY HACKETT COMMENT, AND YOU SHOULD HAVE TAKEN ACTION WHEN YOU DELETED MY POSTS.
NEXT
I AM NEW TO THIS, I DONT WANT TO POST ANYWHERE ELSE BECAUSE I LIKE THIS FORUM, I HAVE BEEN READING IT FOR A WHILE AND DECIDED TO JOIN, DONT GET MAD AT ME FOR NOT KNOWING ALL OF THE RULES.
SUMMARY.
THIS IS ALL JUST A STUPID CONTROVERSY BETWEEN A COUPLE OF MEMBERS, SOME PEOPLE DIDNT DO THEIR JOBS RIGHT AND SOME PEOPLE OUTLASHED TOWARDS OTHERS INAPPROPRIATELY, SO LETS JUST ALL ASSUME RESPONSIBILITY.
I HAVE A FEELING THAT THIS IS ALL OVERWITH AS OF NOW, AND IF ITS NOT ALL HELL IS GONNA BREAK LOOSE.
-
- BobcatNation Redshirt
- Posts: 16
- Joined: Sun Dec 04, 2005 11:59 am
I never blamed the moderators, i simply said they did an inadequate job, but thats just like, my opinion man. i have a different attitude than some of you. When i start a conversation with someone, its usually about something stupid that will get people angry, then i brush it off as a joke, a f*cking joke, thats what the hackett comment was, and that was my intentions, its who i am, and if you want to descriminate, do so, ill see you all in hell then.