Bignell and Clark: top BSC returning players
Moderators: rtb, kmax, SonomaCat
-
- Golden Bobcat
- Posts: 7177
- Joined: Mon May 03, 2004 12:44 pm
Bignell and Clark: top BSC returning players
MSU returns the No. 1 player in four of the seven categories the BSC keeps individual stats on.
Sacks - Clark, tackles for loss - Bignell, forced fumbles - Bignell, and recovered fumbles - Clark. They also return the No. 4 (Bignell) and No. 7 (Collins) tacklers in the league. That's a good trio to build around.
Sacks - Clark, tackles for loss - Bignell, forced fumbles - Bignell, and recovered fumbles - Clark. They also return the No. 4 (Bignell) and No. 7 (Collins) tacklers in the league. That's a good trio to build around.
-
- BobcatNation Hall of Famer
- Posts: 3616
- Joined: Mon Nov 21, 2011 11:35 pm
Re: Bignell and Clark: top BSC returning players
Recovering fumbles is almost entirely based on luck. Thats one of the worst stats to keep in all of football. Notice how Manning, or Brady, or Brees is always on top with QB ratings. Fumble recoveries change every single year. Likewise, tackles are a really bad stat. More plays = more tackles. A solid player on a bad D is going to rack up way more tackles than anyone on a great D that forces 3 & out on every possession.iaafan wrote:MSU returns the No. 1 player in four of the seven categories the BSC keeps individual stats on.
Sacks - Clark, tackles for loss - Bignell, forced fumbles - Bignell, and recovered fumbles - Clark. They also return the No. 4 (Bignell) and No. 7 (Collins) tacklers in the league. That's a good trio to build around.
Tackles for loss, though, and forced fumbles: those are based on individual performance, are repeatable, and aren't a sign of being on a bad D. I had no idea Clark had done that in his half season, and that Bignell forced that many. Kudos to both of them. Great couple of players to build a D around.
- BleedingBLue
- Golden Bobcat
- Posts: 6187
- Joined: Mon Dec 07, 2015 1:00 pm
Re: Bignell and Clark: top BSC returning players
" A solid player on a bad D is going to rack up way more tackles than anyone on a great D that forces 3 & out on every possession." This confuses me. Did Bobby Daly play on a bad D? Is that why he racked up so many tackles?! And that's just one example.onceacat wrote:Recovering fumbles is almost entirely based on luck. Thats one of the worst stats to keep in all of football. Notice how Manning, or Brady, or Brees is always on top with QB ratings. Fumble recoveries change every single year. Likewise, tackles are a really bad stat. More plays = more tackles. A solid player on a bad D is going to rack up way more tackles than anyone on a great D that forces 3 & out on every possession.iaafan wrote:MSU returns the No. 1 player in four of the seven categories the BSC keeps individual stats on.
Sacks - Clark, tackles for loss - Bignell, forced fumbles - Bignell, and recovered fumbles - Clark. They also return the No. 4 (Bignell) and No. 7 (Collins) tacklers in the league. That's a good trio to build around.
Tackles for loss, though, and forced fumbles: those are based on individual performance, are repeatable, and aren't a sign of being on a bad D. I had no idea Clark had done that in his half season, and that Bignell forced that many. Kudos to both of them. Great couple of players to build a D around.
-
- Golden Bobcat
- Posts: 7177
- Joined: Mon May 03, 2004 12:44 pm
Re: Bignell and Clark: top BSC returning players
Stats are deceptive, but you can't discount them. Fumble recoveries do fall in your lap sometimes, but they're like loose balls in basketball. Somebody has to go get it and it's often the more aggressive player willing to fight for it that does. Clark also had three forced fumbles to go along with his two fumble recoveries. Bignell had four FF and recovered one. That's a combination of five FF/FR. No one else on the team had more than 2. That reinforces what I already know about them. They're tough, scrappy players on top of being talented. They compete and fight at a high level. Clark did all that despite seeing very limited action the first few weeks of the season. I don't recall if he started any games. If he did it was just one or two.
- CARDIAC_CATS
- Golden Bobcat
- Posts: 7854
- Joined: Mon Mar 29, 2004 11:37 am
Re: Bignell and Clark: top BSC returning players
Exactly, fumbles are very much like loose balls in basketball. It is about effort. We saw a nice case of effort with fumbles in the Superbowl this year if I am not mistakeniaafan wrote:Stats are deceptive, but you can't discount them. Fumble recoveries do fall in your lap sometimes, but they're like loose balls in basketball. Somebody has to go get it and it's often the more aggressive player willing to fight for it that does. Clark also had three forced fumbles to go along with his two fumble recoveries. Bignell had four FF and recovered one. That's a combination of five FF/FR. No one else on the team had more than 2. That reinforces what I already know about them. They're tough, scrappy players on top of being talented. They compete and fight at a high level. Clark did all that despite seeing very limited action the first few weeks of the season. I don't recall if he started any games. If he did it was just one or two.
-
- Golden Bobcat
- Posts: 4415
- Joined: Thu Jan 20, 2011 1:11 am
Re: Bignell and Clark: top BSC returning players
What he's saying is on s bad defense one has more opportunities to get a tackle. Therefore, eating a player off of overall tackles can be deceiving. A better stat would be something like # of tackles per play/snaps.BleedingBLue wrote:" A solid player on a bad D is going to rack up way more tackles than anyone on a great D that forces 3 & out on every possession." This confuses me. Did Bobby Daly play on a bad D? Is that why he racked up so many tackles?! And that's just one example.onceacat wrote:Recovering fumbles is almost entirely based on luck. Thats one of the worst stats to keep in all of football. Notice how Manning, or Brady, or Brees is always on top with QB ratings. Fumble recoveries change every single year. Likewise, tackles are a really bad stat. More plays = more tackles. A solid player on a bad D is going to rack up way more tackles than anyone on a great D that forces 3 & out on every possession.iaafan wrote:MSU returns the No. 1 player in four of the seven categories the BSC keeps individual stats on.
Sacks - Clark, tackles for loss - Bignell, forced fumbles - Bignell, and recovered fumbles - Clark. They also return the No. 4 (Bignell) and No. 7 (Collins) tacklers in the league. That's a good trio to build around.
Tackles for loss, though, and forced fumbles: those are based on individual performance, are repeatable, and aren't a sign of being on a bad D. I had no idea Clark had done that in his half season, and that Bignell forced that many. Kudos to both of them. Great couple of players to build a D around.
-
- BobcatNation Hall of Famer
- Posts: 3616
- Joined: Mon Nov 21, 2011 11:35 pm
Re: Bignell and Clark: top BSC returning players
Thank you for clarifying that for me. There are just lots of ways that # of tackles can be deceiving. A tackle can be for no gain, or it can be after the runner carried you 10 yards. Most plays end with a tackle, but that tells you very little about the performance of the defender. Yes, Daly had a ton of tackles-in part because the D was designed to make him a top tackler. But the reason you know he was truly great was that he had a boatload of sacks & tackles for loss. Clark & Bignell being leaders in TFL and Sacks is a good sign.bobcat99 wrote:What he's saying is on s bad defense one has more opportunities to get a tackle. Therefore, eating a player off of overall tackles can be deceiving. A better stat would be something like # of tackles per play/snaps.BleedingBLue wrote:" A solid player on a bad D is going to rack up way more tackles than anyone on a great D that forces 3 & out on every possession." This confuses me. Did Bobby Daly play on a bad D? Is that why he racked up so many tackles?! And that's just one example.onceacat wrote:Recovering fumbles is almost entirely based on luck. Thats one of the worst stats to keep in all of football. Notice how Manning, or Brady, or Brees is always on top with QB ratings. Fumble recoveries change every single year. Likewise, tackles are a really bad stat. More plays = more tackles. A solid player on a bad D is going to rack up way more tackles than anyone on a great D that forces 3 & out on every possession.iaafan wrote:MSU returns the No. 1 player in four of the seven categories the BSC keeps individual stats on.
Sacks - Clark, tackles for loss - Bignell, forced fumbles - Bignell, and recovered fumbles - Clark. They also return the No. 4 (Bignell) and No. 7 (Collins) tacklers in the league. That's a good trio to build around.
Tackles for loss, though, and forced fumbles: those are based on individual performance, are repeatable, and aren't a sign of being on a bad D. I had no idea Clark had done that in his half season, and that Bignell forced that many. Kudos to both of them. Great couple of players to build a D around.
-
- BobcatNation Team Captain
- Posts: 713
- Joined: Tue Mar 08, 2005 9:32 pm
- Location: Missoula, MT
Re: Bignell and Clark: top BSC returning players
Are you referring to career stats? The BSC leader in sacks last year is playing in the NFL this year.iaafan wrote:MSU returns the No. 1 player in four of the seven categories the BSC keeps individual stats on.
Sacks - Clark, tackles for loss - Bignell, forced fumbles - Bignell, and recovered fumbles - Clark. They also return the No. 4 (Bignell) and No. 7 (Collins) tacklers in the league. That's a good trio to build around.
Sent from my SM-N920V using Tapatalk
- LTown Cat
- Golden Bobcat
- Posts: 5580
- Joined: Mon Mar 20, 2006 4:26 pm
- Location: Lewistown, MT
Re: Bignell and Clark: top BSC returning players
Of returning players he led is the way I read it.grizband wrote:Are you referring to career stats? The BSC leader in sacks last year is playing in the NFL this year.iaafan wrote:MSU returns the No. 1 player in four of the seven categories the BSC keeps individual stats on.
Sacks - Clark, tackles for loss - Bignell, forced fumbles - Bignell, and recovered fumbles - Clark. They also return the No. 4 (Bignell) and No. 7 (Collins) tacklers in the league. That's a good trio to build around.
Sent from my SM-N920V using Tapatalk
-
- BobcatNation Team Captain
- Posts: 713
- Joined: Tue Mar 08, 2005 9:32 pm
- Location: Missoula, MT
Re: Bignell and Clark: top BSC returning players
That makes sense, thanks!LTown Cat wrote:Of returning players he led is the way I read it.grizband wrote:Are you referring to career stats? The BSC leader in sacks last year is playing in the NFL this year.iaafan wrote:MSU returns the No. 1 player in four of the seven categories the BSC keeps individual stats on.
Sacks - Clark, tackles for loss - Bignell, forced fumbles - Bignell, and recovered fumbles - Clark. They also return the No. 4 (Bignell) and No. 7 (Collins) tacklers in the league. That's a good trio to build around.
Sent from my SM-N920V using Tapatalk
Sent from my SM-N920V using Tapatalk
- luckyirishguy25
- Golden Bobcat
- Posts: 5524
- Joined: Fri Dec 03, 2010 7:59 pm
- Location: Seattle, WA
Re: Bignell and Clark: top BSC returning players
Reading is kryptonite to griz fansLTown Cat wrote:Of returning players he led is the way I read it.grizband wrote:Are you referring to career stats? The BSC leader in sacks last year is playing in the NFL this year.iaafan wrote:MSU returns the No. 1 player in four of the seven categories the BSC keeps individual stats on.
Sacks - Clark, tackles for loss - Bignell, forced fumbles - Bignell, and recovered fumbles - Clark. They also return the No. 4 (Bignell) and No. 7 (Collins) tacklers in the league. That's a good trio to build around.
Sent from my SM-N920V using Tapatalk
-
- BobcatNation Team Captain
- Posts: 713
- Joined: Tue Mar 08, 2005 9:32 pm
- Location: Missoula, MT
Re: Bignell and Clark: top BSC returning players
Toucheluckyirishguy25 wrote:Reading is kryptonite to griz fansLTown Cat wrote:Of returning players he led is the way I read it.grizband wrote:Are you referring to career stats? The BSC leader in sacks last year is playing in the NFL this year.iaafan wrote:MSU returns the No. 1 player in four of the seven categories the BSC keeps individual stats on.
Sacks - Clark, tackles for loss - Bignell, forced fumbles - Bignell, and recovered fumbles - Clark. They also return the No. 4 (Bignell) and No. 7 (Collins) tacklers in the league. That's a good trio to build around.
Sent from my SM-N920V using Tapatalk
Sent from my SM-N920V using Tapatalk