I agree with this post. Even my wife, an objective fan, who thankfully has put up with me during bobcat seasons for the past three years said to me, "Shouldn't this be partly on Ash? The Cats seem to lose big games at the end of the year." I could only agree with her. I think her other comment was, "Maybe Ash has hit his ceiling." Our recruiting while he has been here has been better. I like how he has built the team with high school grads, rather than the JC route. However, history has repeated itself again. Year in and year out, same story. I wonder if Ash could use a fresh start somewhere else? It appears we could use some different strategies for how we approach big games. Personally, I'm a little tired of the "its just another game" mentality. There is one thing for being level headed, its another to be prepared and hyped knowing you can win and dominate. We have been more aggressive this year, and to get over this late season hump, we will need to be even more so. Treat big games as big games.083190 wrote:Love Ash or hate him, it is safe to say his teams have been unsuccessful in big games more often than not, While for the most part, he has done what he was hired to do, his record in "big games" illustrates that by any measure he has not "over-achieved". Good person, Average game coach.
"Ash never wins the big games"
Moderators: rtb, kmax, SonomaCat
- Common Cat
- BobcatNation Hall of Famer
- Posts: 3168
- Joined: Thu Jun 07, 2007 9:10 am
- Location: Spokane
Re: "Ash never wins the big games"
@rfoley77 @rrcatcast Golden Coolie
-
- BobcatNation Redshirt
- Posts: 94
- Joined: Sat Sep 20, 2014 9:57 pm
Re: "Ash never wins the big games"
Here's the thing about Ash as a coach in my amateur opinion:
Take a look at the griz or EWU or pretty much any other decent team. They all start pretty good, but rusty. As the season goes on, they hone their edges, learn from their mistakes, make the right adjustments, and...get better...as a team. And, they have a desire to WIN as the season ends because they believe that they can WIN and go deep into the playoffs (whether they actually can or not).
Name once that we have seen that pattern under eight years of Ash (or hell, for the last 30 years for that matter). Nope, not us. We start out pretty good, get a little better, and stay there. Year after year after year. That is not the players, as they rotate in and out every couple of years and we honestly have championship caliber players. So, if its not the players, then who's left?
Take a look at the griz or EWU or pretty much any other decent team. They all start pretty good, but rusty. As the season goes on, they hone their edges, learn from their mistakes, make the right adjustments, and...get better...as a team. And, they have a desire to WIN as the season ends because they believe that they can WIN and go deep into the playoffs (whether they actually can or not).
Name once that we have seen that pattern under eight years of Ash (or hell, for the last 30 years for that matter). Nope, not us. We start out pretty good, get a little better, and stay there. Year after year after year. That is not the players, as they rotate in and out every couple of years and we honestly have championship caliber players. So, if its not the players, then who's left?
-
- Member # Retired
- Posts: 2239
- Joined: Thu Nov 16, 2006 7:15 pm
Re: "Ash never wins the big games"
I agree with this. I don't like that Ash preaches "it's just another game" because it isn't. Never has been. When Ash decides to leave, I hope there is a Montana native who applies for the job.77matcat wrote:We played like it's another game. Griz played like it was Cat Griz game
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Men, do your duty.
3-7-77
3-7-77
-
- BobcatNation Team Captain
- Posts: 565
- Joined: Mon Mar 29, 2004 4:32 pm
- Location: Big Sky Country
Re:
MSU won't hire a Montana native...look at their hiring at EVERY high level position on campus! The mentality is, "we have to pay more for out-of-staters to come here and bring their experience/worldliness/enlightened opinions and ideas, because Montanan's aren't as cultured." And, we have to pay them more. I've heard it 100s of times, "That's what we have to do to get 'them' to come here." Then, these same people turn around and brag about how awesome Bozeman and MSU are...but, wait, if the town and University are so awesome, shouldn't we be able to pay them less, especially when they don't have any experience at the position they're accepting? Everyone else who works at MSU, and in most of Bozeman, has to be paid less than the 5/7/15 state average and is supposed to "eat the scenery" why shouldn't they and why wouldn't they want to? To the "elites" (I'm talking about the hiring committee chairs and administration) Montanan's aren't "diverse" enough, don't have enough "experience," and aren't capable of running such important and intricate systems/departments/programs. No Montanan is qualified for these positions. Its Jonathan Gruber syndrome at the state level!FTG06' wrote:I agree with this. I don't like that Ash preaches "it's just another game" because it isn't. Never has been. When Ash decides to leave, I hope there is a Montana native who applies for the job.77matcat wrote:We played like it's another game. Griz played like it was Cat Griz game
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
- Member # Retired
- Posts: 2239
- Joined: Thu Nov 16, 2006 7:15 pm
Re: "Ash never wins the big games"
Good point. This is how MSU ends up with losers like Franke Wilmer.WetWaderMT wrote:MSU won't hire a Montana native...look at their hiring at EVERY high level position on campus! The mentality is, "we have to pay more for out-of-staters to come here and bring their experience/worldliness/enlightened opinions and ideas, because Montanan's aren't as cultured." And, we have to pay them more. I've heard it 100s of times, "That's what we have to do to get 'them' to come here." Then, these same people turn around and brag about how awesome Bozeman and MSU are...but, wait, if the town and University are so awesome, shouldn't we be able to pay them less, especially when they don't have any experience at the position they're accepting? Everyone else who works at MSU, and in most of Bozeman, has to be paid less than the 5/7/15 state average and is supposed to "eat the scenery" why shouldn't they and why wouldn't they want to? To the "elites" (I'm talking about the hiring committee chairs and administration) Montanan's aren't "diverse" enough, don't have enough "experience," and aren't capable of running such important and intricate systems/departments/programs. No Montanan is qualified for these positions. Its Jonathan Gruber syndrome at the state level!FTG06' wrote:I agree with this. I don't like that Ash preaches "it's just another game" because it isn't. Never has been. When Ash decides to leave, I hope there is a Montana native who applies for the job.77matcat wrote:We played like it's another game. Griz played like it was Cat Griz game
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Men, do your duty.
3-7-77
3-7-77
-
- Golden Bobcat
- Posts: 7463
- Joined: Mon Dec 13, 2004 11:05 am
Re:
Man, did you ever hit on a sore subject of mine! Not just MSU but check out the school systems! It's extremely disappointing to go through our faculty lists and look at where they are from and then compare them with any of our neighboring states. Say what you will about the evil school west on I-90, they do a reasonable job of keeping their faculty home grown. It's probably the main reason I voted for Mike Wheat after listening to him speak and I'll paraphrase: "All you rich out of state big money interests, go back to where the hell you're from!"FTG06' wrote:Good point. This is how MSU ends up with losers like Franke Wilmer.WetWaderMT wrote:MSU won't hire a Montana native...look at their hiring at EVERY high level position on campus! The mentality is, "we have to pay more for out-of-staters to come here and bring their experience/worldliness/enlightened opinions and ideas, because Montanan's aren't as cultured." And, we have to pay them more. I've heard it 100s of times, "That's what we have to do to get 'them' to come here." Then, these same people turn around and brag about how awesome Bozeman and MSU are...but, wait, if the town and University are so awesome, shouldn't we be able to pay them less, especially when they don't have any experience at the position they're accepting? Everyone else who works at MSU, and in most of Bozeman, has to be paid less than the 5/7/15 state average and is supposed to "eat the scenery" why shouldn't they and why wouldn't they want to? To the "elites" (I'm talking about the hiring committee chairs and administration) Montanan's aren't "diverse" enough, don't have enough "experience," and aren't capable of running such important and intricate systems/departments/programs. No Montanan is qualified for these positions. Its Jonathan Gruber syndrome at the state level!FTG06' wrote:I agree with this. I don't like that Ash preaches "it's just another game" because it isn't. Never has been. When Ash decides to leave, I hope there is a Montana native who applies for the job.77matcat wrote:We played like it's another game. Griz played like it was Cat Griz game
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
- Member # Retired
- Posts: 2319
- Joined: Thu Oct 08, 2009 2:36 pm
- Location: Bozeman
Re:
Truth. That lady is the most worthless professor on campus (right next to Jerry Johnson).FTG06' wrote:Good point. This is how MSU ends up with losers like Franke Wilmer.WetWaderMT wrote:MSU won't hire a Montana native...look at their hiring at EVERY high level position on campus! The mentality is, "we have to pay more for out-of-staters to come here and bring their experience/worldliness/enlightened opinions and ideas, because Montanan's aren't as cultured." And, we have to pay them more. I've heard it 100s of times, "That's what we have to do to get 'them' to come here." Then, these same people turn around and brag about how awesome Bozeman and MSU are...but, wait, if the town and University are so awesome, shouldn't we be able to pay them less, especially when they don't have any experience at the position they're accepting? Everyone else who works at MSU, and in most of Bozeman, has to be paid less than the 5/7/15 state average and is supposed to "eat the scenery" why shouldn't they and why wouldn't they want to? To the "elites" (I'm talking about the hiring committee chairs and administration) Montanan's aren't "diverse" enough, don't have enough "experience," and aren't capable of running such important and intricate systems/departments/programs. No Montanan is qualified for these positions. Its Jonathan Gruber syndrome at the state level!FTG06' wrote:I agree with this. I don't like that Ash preaches "it's just another game" because it isn't. Never has been. When Ash decides to leave, I hope there is a Montana native who applies for the job.77matcat wrote:We played like it's another game. Griz played like it was Cat Griz game
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
- Golden Bobcat
- Posts: 7463
- Joined: Mon Dec 13, 2004 11:05 am
Re: "Ash never wins the big games"
And while you're on the subject of out of state faculty, what about the athletic department? What's the deal there with not hiring more than a few of our former players? I know every year since fields has been at MSU it's been suggested to him numerous times to take the coaches to the huge concentrations of MSU grads in large metropolitan areas and that they could use some help facilitating booster clubs. Much too inconvenient for him and his staff I suppose.
We spend a great deal of time counting where our student-athletes played high school sports but we don't do a very good job of supporting our own once they graduate and I'm sure the rest of the country appreciates the relief our school is providing for their overloaded schools.
We spend a great deal of time counting where our student-athletes played high school sports but we don't do a very good job of supporting our own once they graduate and I'm sure the rest of the country appreciates the relief our school is providing for their overloaded schools.
-
- Member # Retired
- Posts: 2239
- Joined: Thu Nov 16, 2006 7:15 pm
Re: "Ash never wins the big games"
Little known fact: Fields is from Presque Isle, Maine. If MSU has a problem, it's an east coast problem. If I was to make an observation about east coasters compared to us Montanans, east coasters are very self centered.Cat Grad wrote:And while you're on the subject of out of state faculty, what about the athletic department? What's the deal there with not hiring more than a few of our former players? I know every year since fields has been at MSU it's been suggested to him numerous times to take the coaches to the huge concentrations of MSU grads in large metropolitan areas and that they could use some help facilitating booster clubs. Much too inconvenient for him and his staff I suppose.
We spend a great deal of time counting where our student-athletes played high school sports but we don't do a very good job of supporting our own once they graduate and I'm sure the rest of the country appreciates the relief our school is providing for their overloaded schools.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Men, do your duty.
3-7-77
3-7-77
-
- Golden Bobcat
- Posts: 7463
- Joined: Mon Dec 13, 2004 11:05 am
Re:
I've never had very good experiences with those from the northeast, but I suppose it has a lot to do with my personal interests. Plus, fields is another NAIA product and it seems if we are sincere about overall qualifications throughout the campus, one would be much happier with staff and faculty from more prestigious venues.FTG06' wrote:Little known fact: Fields is from Presque Isle, Maine. If MSU has a problem, it's an east coast problem. If I was to make an observation about east coasters compared to us Montanans, east coasters are very self centered.Cat Grad wrote:And while you're on the subject of out of state faculty, what about the athletic department? What's the deal there with not hiring more than a few of our former players? I know every year since fields has been at MSU it's been suggested to him numerous times to take the coaches to the huge concentrations of MSU grads in large metropolitan areas and that they could use some help facilitating booster clubs. Much too inconvenient for him and his staff I suppose.
We spend a great deal of time counting where our student-athletes played high school sports but we don't do a very good job of supporting our own once they graduate and I'm sure the rest of the country appreciates the relief our school is providing for their overloaded schools.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
You do realize he was a wrestler, so what would his level of expertise truly bring to our campus and especially in light of the fact he was little more than an intern assisting with fund raising in Columbia with Missouri? Between him and the previous administration, what has he cost MSU in lost litigation how many times?
-
- Member # Retired
- Posts: 2549
- Joined: Wed Aug 28, 2013 8:12 pm
"Ash never wins the big games"
We do seem to struggle with big games or In some cases melt down. Not sure that I think the coach should go but I do think we ought to get him help. I have said this a couple of times for the past couple of years.
Hire a sports psychologist to evaluate the approach we take. Something seems to be off.
As a junior in high school I played on an over achieving team and we beat a team that should have been champs. Next year with a good portion of the team back we failed.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Hire a sports psychologist to evaluate the approach we take. Something seems to be off.
As a junior in high school I played on an over achieving team and we beat a team that should have been champs. Next year with a good portion of the team back we failed.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
- BobcatNation Redshirt
- Posts: 11
- Joined: Tue Nov 18, 2014 9:54 am
Re: "Ash never wins the big games"
MSU01 wrote:I understand where some of the criticism of the coaching staff comes from, although I prefer to stay out of it as those guys on the sidelines have forgotten 10 times more about football than I will ever know. But can we at least end the "Ash can't win the big games" thing now? If this wasn't a big game I'm not sure what is.
Big games are games against ranked opponents, the Friz, or playoffs. Winning regular conference games against unranked opponents is NOT a big game. Ash is a good teacher but I just don't think he is a motivator. Our Cats seem flat or outmatched every year against the Griz. How can they not match the intensity of the Friz each year?!
You can't spell dumb without UM...Guck the Friz!
Bobcats = 3 National Titles (we won 3 before they won 1...STILL playing catchup)
Griz = 2 National Titles
Bobcats = 3 National Titles (we won 3 before they won 1...STILL playing catchup)
Griz = 2 National Titles
-
- Honorable Mention All-BobcatNation
- Posts: 910
- Joined: Mon Nov 19, 2007 9:25 pm
Re:
[quote="FTG06'"][quote="Cat Grad"]And while you're on the subject of out of state faculty, what about the athletic department? What's the deal there with not hiring more than a few of our former players? I know every year since fields has been at MSU it's been suggested to him numerous times to take the coaches to the huge concentrations of MSU grads in large metropolitan areas and that they could use some help facilitating booster clubs. Much too inconvenient for him and his staff I suppose.
We spend a great deal of time counting where our student-athletes played high school sports but we don't do a very good job of supporting our own once they graduate and I'm sure the rest of the country appreciates the relief our school is providing for their overloaded schools.[/quote]
Little known fact: Fields is from Presque Isle, Maine. If MSU has a problem, it's an east coast problem. If I was to make an observation about east coasters compared to us Montanans, east coasters are very self centered.
Sent from my iPad using [url=http://tapatalk.com/m?id=1]Tapatalk[/url][/quote]
WOW! That is a pretty broad stroke you are painting with.
We spend a great deal of time counting where our student-athletes played high school sports but we don't do a very good job of supporting our own once they graduate and I'm sure the rest of the country appreciates the relief our school is providing for their overloaded schools.[/quote]
Little known fact: Fields is from Presque Isle, Maine. If MSU has a problem, it's an east coast problem. If I was to make an observation about east coasters compared to us Montanans, east coasters are very self centered.
Sent from my iPad using [url=http://tapatalk.com/m?id=1]Tapatalk[/url][/quote]
WOW! That is a pretty broad stroke you are painting with.
- NrthFce
- BobcatNation Team Captain
- Posts: 569
- Joined: Thu Oct 11, 2007 9:13 am
- Location: Bozone
Re: Re:
I must agreeTrueCat wrote:WOW! That is a pretty broad stroke you are painting with.FTG06' wrote:Little known fact: Fields is from Presque Isle, Maine. If MSU has a problem, it's an east coast problem. If I was to make an observation about east coasters compared to us Montanans, east coasters are very self centered.Cat Grad wrote:And while you're on the subject of out of state faculty, what about the athletic department? What's the deal there with not hiring more than a few of our former players? I know every year since fields has been at MSU it's been suggested to him numerous times to take the coaches to the huge concentrations of MSU grads in large metropolitan areas and that they could use some help facilitating booster clubs. Much too inconvenient for him and his staff I suppose.
We spend a great deal of time counting where our student-athletes played high school sports but we don't do a very good job of supporting our own once they graduate and I'm sure the rest of the country appreciates the relief our school is providing for their overloaded schools.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
MSU Alumni!
-
- Member # Retired
- Posts: 2239
- Joined: Thu Nov 16, 2006 7:15 pm
Re: "Ash never wins the big games"
I've lived in every part of this country, from the west coast, to the Midwest, the south, and now the east coast. Believe me, I have perspective.TrueCat wrote:WOW! That is a pretty broad stroke you are painting with.FTG06' wrote:Little known fact: Fields is from Presque Isle, Maine. If MSU has a problem, it's an east coast problem. If I was to make an observation about east coasters compared to us Montanans, east coasters are very self centered.Cat Grad wrote:And while you're on the subject of out of state faculty, what about the athletic department? What's the deal there with not hiring more than a few of our former players? I know every year since fields has been at MSU it's been suggested to him numerous times to take the coaches to the huge concentrations of MSU grads in large metropolitan areas and that they could use some help facilitating booster clubs. Much too inconvenient for him and his staff I suppose.
We spend a great deal of time counting where our student-athletes played high school sports but we don't do a very good job of supporting our own once they graduate and I'm sure the rest of the country appreciates the relief our school is providing for their overloaded schools.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
But that really has nothing to do with the thread, so I'll shut up now.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Men, do your duty.
3-7-77
3-7-77
- wbtfg
- Golden Bobcat
- Posts: 13621
- Joined: Sat Apr 03, 2004 12:52 pm
Re: "Ash never wins the big games"
Jason McEndoo @JasonMcEndoo 22m22 minutes ago
I've coached long enough to know that the people patting you on the back are sometimes the ones stabbing u in the back.................#CHiP
I've coached long enough to know that the people patting you on the back are sometimes the ones stabbing u in the back.................#CHiP
- tampa_griz
- Golden Bobcat
- Posts: 5467
- Joined: Thu Nov 17, 2005 1:37 pm
- Location: St. Petersburg, FL
Re: "Ash never wins the big games"
Ouch.wbtfg wrote:Jason McEndoo @JasonMcEndoo 22m22 minutes ago
I've coached long enough to know that the people patting you on the back are sometimes the ones stabbing u in the back.................#CHiP
-
- BobcatNation Letterman
- Posts: 191
- Joined: Thu Oct 04, 2012 4:22 pm
Re: "Ash never wins the big games"
Wow, that is some kind of tweet there and I suspect spot on given the atmosphere around here after a loss.wbtfg wrote:Jason McEndoo @JasonMcEndoo 22m22 minutes ago
I've coached long enough to know that the people patting you on the back are sometimes the ones stabbing u in the back.................#CHiP
-
- Golden Bobcat
- Posts: 19075
- Joined: Thu Oct 23, 2008 6:16 am
- Location: An endless run of moguls
Re: "Ash never wins the big games"
Everyone, from coaches to players to fans, better move on or this SDSU game isn't going to go well. Cramsey said last night that they can't let one less loss turn into two losses. If MSU doesn't put this Cat-Griz game behind it, it'll do just that.
MSU - 15 team National Champions (most recent 2021); 57 individual National Champions (most recent 2023).
toM StUber
toM StUber
-
- 1st Team All-BobcatNation
- Posts: 1876
- Joined: Tue Dec 04, 2012 10:27 pm
Re: "Ash never wins the big games"
Exactly, great point by him and by you Tom. Nothing can possibly be gained from re-living that game, we all saw what happened. Burn the tape and scatter the ashes, and focus on SDSU, because they deserve our full attention. So many on here say you want to compete for Big Sky and National championships, which I think we all agree with. Here's our chance to take the first step toward that championship run. Do I believe we have that type of run in us? Not sure, but I'm looking forward to watching this week and seeing how it goes, and I'll be there in the snow yelling my fool head off!TomCat88 wrote:Everyone, from coaches to players to fans, better move on or this SDSU game isn't going to go well. Cramsey said last night that they can't let one less loss turn into two losses. If MSU doesn't put this Cat-Griz game behind it, it'll do just that.